Friday Facts

A friend’s blog post made me realize that it was time for me to share some information. Random musings and I’ll post this occasionally on a Friday.

Today’s Friday Facts are about me:

1. I’m a Cancer–yes, a crab. Some days it really fits.

2. I’m the oldest of five.

3. I cannot stand the smell of fish and do not eat fish.

4. I can’t tolerate gluten and dairy, but I occasionally eat them and pay a price.

5. I’ve been vegan before and am currently mostly vegetarian.

6. I have two Calico cats–Arwen and Hermione. Yes, one is names for a character in Lord of the Rings and the other from Harry Potter.

7. I am scared to death and fascinated by the reanimated dead–yes, zombies. Cringes.

8. I almost always have nuts in my bag or in my car. Good source of fast protein to even blood sugar.

9. Almost everyday I miss my family in California and the good weather.

10. I love to read–books, magazines, you name it. I always have reading material on me, in my car or in different locations around my house.

Teaching Peer Reviews

This last week I had my second set of Peer Review for my third year appointment process. I’ve thought about the review process and then read one set of the reviews and have come to a few thoughts about my teaching.

The first thing that I’m thinking about is how important it is to come into the classroom feeling comfortable with your abilities and the material that you’re going to teach. I know that I’ve taught courses that were outside of my major areas of training and the classes have gone well. Likewise, I’ve taught courses in my major area and for whatever reason that particular course was mediocre at times. Many things can make a class successful or weak, however, in my experience the instructor’s attitude is extremely important to the class environment.

The second thing that I’m struck with is my readiness with examples for the students. I find that some days I won’t refer to the extra examples that I have up my sleeve for discussion and other times we’ll review all of them. I’ve taught the same class back to back, but different sections (or groups of students) and the classes are markedly different based on the students. A mentor once told me that she used to come to class with a planned joke. I never tried that—I find that if I have a joke to say it will come to me and there are times when the unplanned joke bombs. This is OK. They usually still laugh, but it’s a kind laugh at me and not the joke. I use American pronunciation for words and at times the Canadian students have laughed or asked for me to repeat a word—this is fine. I’ve never taken offense.

The third thing that might sound arbitrary in some ways, but many students today really expect most instructors to use some sort of technology. When you don’t use any technology or slides, it can come off as endearing or that you are out of touch with their learning needs. Now, whether or not you make the slides, outlines or technology available to them is another conversation! I have mixed feelings about this and will save my comments about this for a different blog post.

In my conversation with students, I have also found that they are not at ease with the instructor who only relies on notes and doesn’t walk around the room some. As a matter of fact, I noticed in my Peer Review that my apparent lack of use of notes was noted. Well, I did have a skeleton outline, but I didn’t really refer to it. I like to walk around the classroom and have heard this “tactic” keeps students awake (!) or focused. I get excited about the material at times and I just need to walk and talk.

As I’ve noted previously on this blog, I also learn from each class and look forward to my continued ruminations about my teaching. My teaching is a work in progress and I’m the first one to admit this.

Advice about Undergraduate Thesis Committees

If you’re thinking of asking a faculty member to sit on your honors thesis committee there are a few things you need to think about beforehand.

Is your project’s timeline realistic? Can you finish in time to graduate? In some programs, students will have to take additional courses for the honors program and you will have ample opportunity to think about your project. Use this time to also think about your timeline and who you will ask to sit on your committee.

How busy are you? Will you make your deadlines? Remember that your committee is also very busy and that they are counting on you to meet your deadlines and habitually missing deadlines is a poor reflection on your time management and is an inconvenience to your committee. Essentially you are telling your committee that their time is also not important and this is not a smart tactic to take.

Are the committee members a good fit for your project? Do the committee members have a good reputation for mentoring students and guiding them through the process? You will work closely with the committee for several months. Then, at your defense you will want to make sure that they understand the project and are there on your side to help you think critically about the project.

Try to surround yourself with a strong support network of friends and peers in the department who will also understand what you are going through with the thesis. The thesis can provide you the first taste of what graduate school is like and you want this to work for you.

Use the resources (if any) available at your university. See if there is a Writing Lab or Writing Center to help you with the writing process. Your committee could offer you writing advice, but other committees might focus more strongly on the concepts and encourage you to work with someone else for the writing. These are things you will need to discuss with your committee.

Likewise, find out what the department culture is. Is the Chair the “heavy” and the second committee member only comes on for the defense? You will need to ask these questions. I would suggest that you also get input from your Chair about who they think might be a good second committee member. You might propose a few names, but be open to the Chair’s suggestions. Faculty are more aware of other colleagues’ workloads or even their assessment’s of students, so your Chair might suggest that you pursue alternative options. S/he might know of a perfect fit in another department. Also, your Chair might not really have any investment in who the second committee member is—again you will need to have this discussion with the Chair of your committee.

This might sound harsh—but faculty do not have to sit on Undergraduate Thesis or Dissertation committees. We can pick students who we want to work with  and mentor, and some faculty are notoriously burdened with too much committee work. You want a good mentor who has time for you, so ask wisely. Please do not take offense if you get a decline or if a faculty member explains that s/he is on leave and not supervising. This is all part of the undergraduate thesis process. We have every right to decline and most times it is not personal.

Do make sure that you talk about the honors program experience with current students who working on their thesis or major research undergraduate project. Your peers can work as an invaluable resource during this process. Good luck!

 

Book Review: Hey Shorty!

I read Hey Shorty!: A Guide to Combating Sexual Harassment in Schools and on the Streets written by the Girls for Gender Equity, Joanne N. Smith, Mandy Van Deven and Meghan Huppuch not sure what to expect. To say that I could not put the book down is a gross understatement. By the time I read a few sections, I had contacted several friends and told them that they had to read this book. I’m going to get my 13 year old her own copy, so that my dog-eared and margin filled copy does not distract her.

The book begins noting that sexual harassment is a real problem for girls and young women and avoids polemic by using the Girls for Gender Equity in New York as the case study. But, this is not some academic tome swooping into a community and then leaving in order to tell the story. Instead, the authors are girls and women who have a connection to the organization. Girls for Gender Equity serves the needs of girls and young women primarily from an underserved population—immigrants, girls of color, the working class and poor.

Some might read the start date of the organization (September 11th 2001) and think that the founding coincided with such a terrible act of terrorism. Yes, this is true, but it was a propitious start to the organization that was meant to build community and give voice to the previously invisible in the community—youth. Now, I will first admit to working in the non-profit sector previously and have also completed contract work for a youth serving non-profit. Girls for Gender Equity is the sort of organization that I wish I worked for and that most youth serving organizations can learn from in terms of not just the mission statement, but the ways in which the girls, parents, schools, and volunteers were all deemed integral parts of the organization.

The first sections of the book really set up how the organization helped the girls name sexual harassment. The sexualization of the girls in their lives was normalized. And, not until they discussed the sexual assault of a neighbourhood girl and other experiences did they have the epiphanies to realize that something was amiss—that something was wrong. The book is written by a set of authors who clearly care about the organization and the issue.

The latter part of the book outlines the ways in which the organization sought to change part of the school curriculum to make sure that Title IX guidelines were followed and to put an end to sexual harassment. The organization hit speed bumps, as it turns out that some bureaucrats truly had no clue about Title IX. Add to this the ways in which some did not fully comprehend the reality of sexual harassment.

Girls for Gender Equity responded with an example of Participatory Action Research (PAR) that would put most other attempts to shame. The Girls for Gender Equity’s PAR study follows the understood guidelines by having the girls involved from the ground up with the study.  Ultimately more than one thousand middle school and high school students across four boroughs were surveyed. The results are a breathtaking example of the ways in which sexual harassment is a daily occurrence for most respondents.

The book’s continued strength is in the voluminous and helpful appendices that include an activist tool kit of sorts with resources for other organizations and schools to follow in order to combat sexual harassment. This book is a must read for parents, girls, allies, educators, and bureaucrats. The tone of the book is not jargon-filled and the audience is vast for this book. Do yourself a favor and buy this book for yourself and for a girl or young woman in your life.

For more information about the book or the book’s virtual tour please see: http://www.indiegogo.com/HeyShortyontheRoad

Teaching Evaluations

I have just reviewed the Course Experience Surveys (CES) for my courses. These are the evaluations and I am pleased with the numbers. I’ll need to ask the admin to see the written comments, which are usually fun to read. We all know that the students who really liked you or didn’t really like you are the ones to leave comments.

Particular to this last school year, I changed a few things and the numbers demonstrated an improvement. One question refers to the assignments and another to fairness with the grading. These two questions really allow the students to comment on the syllabus and the grading performance. Of course, part of this is that the students can blame the instructor for their mark in the class, but that is a different blog post.

The first thing that I’ll admit to is that by and large my CES or evaluations for my courses are normally good to great. But, like any educator focused on teaching and learning, I want to improve my statistics. My enrolments are strong in my courses and I usually have long waitlists for my courses, so I’m doing lots of things right. I won’t rest on my laurels and not try to work on things. And, I’m cognizant that I teach most of the gender courses and other controversial topics, so this influences the evaluations to some degree.

What did I do different you might wonder?  I made special care to talk more about the assignments in class and dedicated more time to do so. I also increased the explanation time when reviewing the syllabus and the assignment.  I joke with colleagues that some students need to hear the explanation three times in order for it to sink in and this might not really be a joke! I did this with all six classes this last year—from first year to seminar.

In some of my classes, I actually included a sample topic sentence outline from the previous term. In other classes, I shared a successful blog. I also shared information about assessment and continued to use my grading grid in the courses. The extra time and the examples made a positive difference with those two questions. Now, I need to think about what I want to work on for next year…

Words of Advice the Teaching Assistant

Some of the varied roles for the Teaching Assistant  (These are not exhaustive)

1) Mediator between student and professor/instructor

2) Facilitator of sections or tutorials; both as an authority figure and as a grader

3) Counselor /mentor (this is ad hoc and will vary for Teaching Assistants)

4) Employee of the department and university

5) Employee of the instructor of record (you report to the him/her)

Preparing for lecture and grading will be the most time-consuming as a TA. Depending on your department culture your office hours could be busy or you may never see a student. Use the office hours to prep for tutorial or grade.

The 3 Cs of professionalism as a Teaching Assistant: competence, confidence and (student) centeredness.

You should walk into the classroom knowing that you are competent, as your department chose you out of a large pile of applicants! Because of this—be confident. And, once you in the classroom remember that the tutorial is about the students and their understanding of the course material (student centeredness).

Things to ask the instructor who you are reporting to: how do they see your role as a Teaching Assistant in the class? What is her/his policy regarding academic dishonesty? Hopefully, you will have regular meetings with the instructor about assignments and the material that the instructor expects you to cover during the tutorials. Will the instructor allow you to offer a mini-lecture or facilitate an extra workshop about writing or an assignment?

You should remember that as a Teaching Assistant you need to effectively facilitate discussion among all the students in the tutorial. With this in mind, watch gestures, metaphors and all comments in class. Try to avoid sports metaphors as they might not make sense to international students or other students who do not follow said sport. Make sure that you are fair to all the students and encourage everyone to participate. This might mean asking one “keen” student to allow others to participate. However, if you do this in a polite manner it should not be a problem.

Whenever you have questions, always go to the instructor. The instructor is really meant to mentor you in your role as an apprentice educator. You are still learning and this will mean that sometimes you do not have all the answers. (Frankly, the instructors are still learning, too!)

My last word of advice—always go to tutorial prepared and professional. This does not mean that you have to purchase an expensive new wardrobe, but do dress appropriately for the department culture. Have fun! You have the lucky position of playing an important role in a student’s life. If you do a good to great job, chances are the students will learn lots and remember you fondly.

Summer School Tips

Summer School sounds like such a great idea—get through some units quickly! Who wouldn’t like that? Well, the reality is that once the sun comes out Summer school no longer seems like such a good idea. Allow me to give you some words of advice.

Go to class! Yes, this is so old school of me, but actually coming to class can help you with your understanding of the material, get to hear what the instructor has to say, and you also have the opportunity to hear the discussion between the instructor and your classmates.

Do the reading! Oh, I know that this is tedious. The materials are assigned for a good reason. You can read them on the beach, whilst you dip your toes in the warm sand or right before you retire for the evening. Just make sure that you review the course materials. If you have a book assigned—always read the preface or introduction, even if it’s not assigned. The pre-matter helps set up the book and it might offer you the epiphany you need prior to reading the longer chapters.

Go to office hours! Yes, this is not merely for the student who does not understand the material or wants to endear him/herself to the instructor. Office hours is a great place to get to know your instructor better and for the instructor to get to know you and your learning style better. This can make a difference.

Study. I already suggested reading the course materials, but studying is something entirely different. If the class has exams or papers, the instructor assumes that you have done more than a skim of the materials. You need to understand the materials and demonstrated comprehension about them. And, here is where studying comes into play. This might include you reviewing the questions at the end of the chapter or looking at the “for future reference” materials or websites.

This last suggestion was really useful for me in graduate school—look through the index. Notice the sorts of words/concepts that are indexed and choose some to re-read again. This can cement the ideas—oh, like a splinter into your mind that you will pull out during the most opportune time. (I just had to throw in a Matrix reference there).

The last thing—care. Seriously. You don’t have to earn an A or shoot for the A, but treat the entire course experience like it matters and you will most likely be more successful. Remember that going to college is a privilege. You might already be keenly aware of this, but in case you’re not—remember that someone would love to trade spots with you and sit in a classroom, read books and articles and write assignments.

Slutwalk and the Feminist Debates

Can I just say that the debates about the veracity of Slutwalk on the WMST-L have really hurt my feminist heart. The Women’s Studies Listserv has several thousand subscribers and the subscribers vary from those in Women’s Studies or other disciplines. You don’t have to be an academic to be on the list and lots of activists and writers subscribe. The WMST-L provides a beacon of feminist information sharing and dare I say networking. Occasionally a debate will transpire on the list among some of the list members.  Once again we have a round of back and forth where the debate is not so much about stopping violence against women, but instead is about semantics and feminist politics. Who has the right to say that they are the most feminist?! Using pornographic languages is apparently problematic and defeats the purpose of the walks. And, the salvos go back and forth.

This is a great example of how some academic feminist ideology not only turns off the mainstream from ideas, but also causes major fissures among the various feminist camps. Now, I’m not so pollyannish to expect us to all get along. What I don’t like, though, is how it appears that the debates become mired in certain conversations that smell of generational bullshit and  one-upwomanship on who owns the most feminist politics. Don’t get me started about how these conversations at times don’t offer an analysis that remembers class, race, sexuality and ability, but that would really complicate things, right?

Can’t we agree that the Police Officer should not have blamed the woman for her dress? He should have not said that she should not dress like a slut. For information about this Toronto situation see: http://www.slutwalktoronto.com/  And, can we agree that he should have kept his mouth shut or perhaps condemned the assailant. Yes, bring men into this discussion. Don’t rape women!

Then, the response with the Slutwalks in Toronto, Victoria and elsewhere was really about reclaiming the word and explaining to the public—don’t rape women. Stop violence against women. You say slut to demean women, well fuck you, we’re taking this word back! We’re going to go out in the public space and use this word and bellow a resounding, no. How is this not empowering? Well, the word is heternormative, demeaning, sexualizes women, and is an example of porn culture. Yes, but the point is that Slutwalk is reclaiming this word—empowering women to say, “Guess what—rape is never acceptable.”

There is power in words. Words are signifiers. We know this. However, we also know that we can take back words and refashion them and say that these words don’t hurt us anymore. Slutwalk is getting press around the globe and when more people talk about curbing violence against women this is a win for feminisms.

But, the debate about this term being problematic is really beside the point in my opinion. I’m sure Inga Muscio is smiling about these debates and thinking back about the flak she got with her first book. But, that my friends, is another blog post.

Mentors: Part I

A good mentor can make your education easier. We all know how isolating the college experience is and how this is exacerbated for first generation college students. Entertaining graduate school is probably one of the scariest things that most college students will do. The process seems mired in the unknown and one of the best ways to navigate this journey is with a good mentor or two.

Your mentor might be a peer mentor—someone who is a year or a few years ahead of you. You might not even realize that you’re getting mentored and the friendship or working mentor/mentee relationship might work well. You might also find mentors among your professors or co-workers. And, these relationships might spawn naturally from the classroom environment, office hours, and other meetings at the university.

Sometimes students will actively seek a mentor and other times the faculty member might pay attention to you and offer her/his mentorship. Either way it is born—try and nourish it. A healthy mentor/mentee relationship is going to mean that you keep in contact with your mentor. This might be the occasional email or appointment. You’ll need to see what works for the two of you.

Some words of advice for grad students:

If you are in the process of writing a thesis, project, or dissertation, you need to keep in contact with the Chair of your committee. This is a common faux pas that graduate students will make. Usually your Chair really wants you to finish and be successful. Most faculty are over-extended when it comes to sitting on students’ committees and the most successful students are the ones who finish. And, these students tend to keep the lines of communication open. This might mean admitting that you’re suffering from writer’s block, imposter syndrome, working a “regular” job, stress or family life is the priority. Just be honest.

Some words of advice for undergraduates:

If you’re in a department that offers graduate degrees, most faculty view the graduate students as the students who have the priority for mentoring. These are the students we can ask to complete research work with, co-author with and get more “service” credit with for our mentoring. Yes, faculty get credit when they Chair a committee or fund graduate students. There is usually an understanding that mentoring graduate students takes more time and work. What this might sound like is that there is a hierarchy—faculty might want to mentor graduate students more. Well, this just might be the case at your institution. If you’re at a small liberal arts college and few graduate degrees are offered, then you are in luck. The faculty will definitely have a mandate to work with and mentor undergraduate students.

Another word of advice for the undergraduates, sometimes the mentoring/mentee relationship just doesn’t work. It might be that you and your tentative mentor don’t click or that your mentor is not good at mentoring. Walk away and don’t give up. There is bound to be another person who will want to listen to you and help you as needed. This is not the rule. I am merely speaking from my 13 years of teaching and even more years as an undergraduate and then graduate student through my four degrees in university.

I’ve found that one of the first steps with mentoring undergrads or graduate students is listening. And, then offering my advice to the student as needed. I’ve also found that occasionally a student is not interested in getting mentored. Some students realize a year or two later that they could use my assistance and others a year after graduation. That is fine. I’m an email or office appointment away.

Time

How do you manage your time? As academics we don’t necessarily work the traditional 9-5 job. In fact, I’d argue that for most of us we work more than 40 hours a week, since we can work different hours and those grading weeks are intensive. I’ll speak to how I manage my time generally speaking. Of course, there are those triage weeks where I am really focusing on what absolutely has to get done!

My priority is teaching, so that is always the main focus at work. Everything else is secondary. Given that my job is a teaching focused position it makes sense that priority numero uno is teaching. But, I do more than teach. I also advise and mentor students and this is also important. Most weeks I would say that this is priority number two during the advising hours and emails. The next priority is my research or the book that I’m working on with two Women’s Studies colleagues.

What I do is schedule in time for my “own” work. I actually schedule this in my Outlook. I do this for numerous reasons. It’s important to note this time and frankly my colleagues on Outlook can see busy bubbles in my schedule. This ensures that I don’t get queried during my research or writing time. The other thing that I have done is more collaborative work with some of my former students. This offers a collaborative conference paper or possible publication and it’s also a mentoring project. These are shared projects that I have found fulfilling.

When I am in the midst of a busy project time (Summer), I will actually time my work and during this time I have to step away from social media ( #socmedia ) in order to stay focused on writing. I also will block in body breaks–stretching, a walk around the building or time for a snack. I know that this might sound very regimented, but it works for me. And, if you know me, you might be smiling and thinking that this sounds like something I would do!

How do you manage your time?